[Population: One] <A HREF="http://popone.innocence.com/ar

[bryant]

Yep, I saw it. Chances are most people reading this will have seen it or will intend to see it (and for the rest, read on for a special offer). So instead of reviewing, I'll ramble.

It's a Michael Moore movie. From some comments I read previously, I expected it to be less of a polemic, and perhaps more objective. Nope -- he's narrating the thing and even if he doesn't come out in front of the camera much, it's still got a heaping helping of Moore sarcasm and innuendo. I think I could have done without mocking members of the Iraq War coalition; even if I don't think Costa Rica made a significant contribution to the war, I still believe the country deserves the same respect as any other sovereign nation. And I noticed that Moore left out England and Spain when listing coalition members.

On the other hand, it's also got some astoundingly effective moments and, yeah, a few things I didn't know. Some of them angered me, and some reminded me that there was a time when Bush didn't look like he could possibly be as bad as he's turned out to be. The Lila Lipscomb segments reached brilliance. Specifically, her reaction to the woman who challenged her. Every Republican should watch the movie for that moment if nothing else: that's the danger you face when you try to brush off criticism.

Which leads me to the special offer. I think people should see this movie, not because it is a magic wand which will convert the masses to frothing Kerry worship but because it shows things you wouldn't otherwise see. It does not present a complete picture. It does present important elements of a complete picture. So if you weren't going to see this movie because you think Moore is a pompous blowhard, I will happily purchase and read a political book of your choosing if you change your mind. Even if it's by Ann Coulter.

(Offer invalid if you pick a book I've already read, so be careful -- you'd be surprised.)

Comments

[ronebofh.livejournal.com]

I'll wait to rent the DVD. I definitely don't care to pay full price. Two of my stepkids, 19 and 21, saw it and weren't impressed. They felt Moore's propaganda got old, even amidst the bits of stuff they didn't know about.

I could have you read one of Sean Hannity's books, but, damn, that's just fuckin' cruel. Read something interesting instead.

[totient]

I may be repeating material from the movie (which I haven't seen yet). But:

I don't think Costa Rica made a significant contribution to the war
That's probably an understatement, given that they don't have an army.